January, 16 2014 09:03:26

Allowing early marriage is a retrograde

by Thu Van

The phrase "Sweet Sixteen" is there for a reason.

I remember when I was 16 and in grade ten, how I cried over the news that a member of a famous pop music group had got married.

Before the heart-breaking news smashed my dreams and aspirations, my path ahead was clear. I would get a scholarship and go the US and marry him.

Today, I can look back and shake my head and have a laugh at my teenage fantasies.

Today, I am shaking my head, but laughter is the farthest thing from my mind. I just heard lawmakers in Viet Nam are proposing lowering the legal marriageable age from 18 to 16.


I knew this could not be true. There must have been some misunderstanding. I looked for clarifications and instead, to my astonishment, found justifications made by members of the drafting committee for the amended Law on Marriage and Family.

Ngo Thi Huong, who holds a PhD from Ha Noi Law University, cited the fact that in many localities, mostly remote and mountainous areas, ethnic minority girls and boys below 18 are still living together and having children. She said because of such customs still exist and are followed, we need to amend the law accordingly.

Another member, Pham Quoc Anh, President of the Viet Nam Bar Association, said girls and boys now grow up faster than previous generations due to their access to mass media, so we should let them get married earlier.

Even the Minister of Justice, Ha Hung Cuong, weighed in on the issue, saying lowering the marriageable age from 18 to 16 is "not too much". He said when one is 17 years and a day old, he or she is considered 18. So actually, the new marriage age, if approved, would only be lowered by one year compared to the current regulation.

All I can do is to shake my head some more and say I respectfully disagree with the above "experts."

My nephew, who just turned 19, is still confused about what he wants. Last May he told me he wanted to study law. Six months later he said he wanted to study nuclear energy abroad. But it's okay not to be certain now, because he still has time to decide which path he is going to pursue. In the years to come, he will become more mature, understand life a bit more, and will keep making choices based on the experiences he has.

Importantly, he will make his career choices, stand on his own legs and be ready to settle down before he decides to get married (or not).

At 16, whether she or he has grown up in the village or in an urban locality in our society, is still an adolescent who is at a transformative stage, and not very emotionally stable to make far-reaching decisions on things like marriage.

Physically, yes, even at 14, girls can give birth. But marriage is not about the ability to give birth. It is about living together with a partner, preparing to be parents, being ready to rear children and preparing them to meet life's challenges.

And at 16, one is still in high school and still has two more years to go before he or she graduates.

Medical experts have said 16 is not the ideal age to bear babies and give birth. They have also said early marriages can become a population growth challenge and lead to more obstetrical accidents.

Apart from the physical and emotional readiness for starting a family life, we cannot afford to ignore the economic perspective, especially in these market-economy oriented days.

Would 16-year-old boys and girls be able to handle the economic challenge of raising a family?

I read every day in Vietnamese newspapers, both online and print editions, that young people in the country lack the experience and skills to cope with life situations and challenges. Marriage is a complicated relationship and would require more experience and skills than most other situations.

Meanwhile, the divorce rate of Viet Nam has been on the rise in recent years, showing more and more adults are failing the marriage test. In 2005, there were about 55,000 divorce cases. In 2008, the number was 65,000 and this went up to 79,000 in 2009. In 2011, it was more than 88,000.

The rate of divorce among couples aged 18 to 30 accounts for 35 per cent of the total, it is said.

Going back to the argument of backing the ethnic minority custom of early marriage, it was just two days ago that this very newspaper carried a story about a ninth grade girl publicly threatening to commit suicide rather than get married. She also said she wanted to continue her studies.

This girl can be considered more mature than some of the adults around, it seems.

None of the arguments I have heard so far have failed to convince me that there are justifiable grounds for lowering the marriage age to 16. No scientific or even sociological evidence has been cited.

Authorities should brainstorm and find solutions to help children and youth better protect themselves from the negative impacts of a fast-changing society, instead of considering retrograde steps.

If children are having sex at earlier age, the answer is to educate them about safe sex. We cannot tell them: "Well, now you can have sex legally at 16, so try to wait for a few more months."

We need future generations that are well educated and prepared to tackle many challenges that the country is set to face. Allowing them to get married at 16 will not help.

Let us not open the door to making sweet sixteen a bitter experience. — VNS

wolfgang - rainwolf@earthlink.net   wolfgang
January, 22 2014 14:27:08
It is sad to read that marriage at 16 years old could become legal in Viet Nam. I love Viet Nam and Vietnamese culture, however, the high pressure to marry and have children before one is old enough to even know how to engage this increasingly difficult world, is truly frightening, and I see the desperation and slave-like conditions it leads girls and young women into, and the lack of adequate parenting and education that results from it. Please Viet Nam, protect your children and potential grandchildren from this misguided and enslaving idea. Wait to get married and you will have much happier, healthier and more successful children!
Cain - cbynum2@murraystate.edu   Cain
January, 20 2014 10:41:20
I am an American, and as such I can tell you that the idea that individuals getting married at 16 is absurd. I am 21 years old and in college, and even I cannot fathom the idea of marriage yet. I am a adult in America, and I have worked ever since I was 13 years old, but that does not qualify me for marriage. Marriage is a serious decision, and it is permanent. The government allowing marriage at 16 is stupidity at its worst, however that is not the problem. The problem is that children must be taught the correct decisions. I know many Vietnamese who do this, and I have started to appreciate Vietnamese culture in that sense. This is a crazy notion, and I hope it does not pass through Vietnam's government. As an American, I can attest that it is not a good idea to encourage marriage at a young age, it is a good idea to encourage maturity, and above all, the correct decisions of taking marriage seriously.
Duc Huan Tran - tranduchuan@humg.edu.vn   Duc Huan Tran
January, 18 2014 19:50:21
You have my hat off those who are so-called "experts". I think to totally ged rid of 'child marriage' situation, these "experts" should propose to allow legally married at the age of "eight" and "ten" instead of 16 and 18. That would be a great idea!
Tu Vien - ellynguyen1981@gmail.com   Tu Vien
January, 16 2014 11:36:30
In my point of view, we should have a directly look on the fact that fast-changing society not occured only Viet Nam but also over the world. We should find the way to adapt, as well as how to teach young generation having meaning life. Therefore, we should not look down like getting married too early from 16 year old, those who do not have enough knowledge to do understand family life. I agree with the author that we should teach young about safe sex if this issue is the most important in nowadays. Beside, avoiding raise new life style with new think that only wait few months to get 16 years old that means legal having sex, legal getting married.
Send Us Your Comments:
Your E-mail address:

VietNamNews may edit your comments and not all emails will be published.


Environmental issues hinder new rural areas Environmental issues hinder new rural areas

In the five years since the Government put in place Decision No 49/QD-TTg on 19 criteria for new-style rural areas for the 2010-20 period, the majority of communes across the nation fail to meet the 17th criterion on environment. Both local and central authorities find it difficult to fill all five norms, as set down.

Baby vaccinations remain a cause for concern Baby vaccinations remain a cause for concern

Parents are concerned about post-vaccine reactions after the recent death of babies after receiving Quinvaxem vaccine, although the Health Ministry has repeatedly confirmed the safety of the vaccine.

Photos strengthen confidence of Mong girls Photos strengthen confidence of Mong girls

Wearing her most beautiful dress, Vu Thi Vu smiles broadly as she shows to her friends one of her photos which are on display at the Can Chu Phin secondary school in Meo Vac district of northernmost Ha Giang Province.

Lack of fire safety a risk in high-rises Lack of fire safety a risk in high-rises

Negligence and ignorance of fire safety regulations by both investors and residents at high-rise buildings have again come to the fore following the latest blaze in Ha Noi.